Place cider, coconut milk and pumpkin puree in a saucepan and heat over medium heat until it just about boils. (You can also heat the ingredients in a mug in the microwave)
Remove from heat and place in blender with the remaining ingredients. Blend on medium-high until everything is combined, about one minute. Pour into mug and sprinkle with a dash more of cinnamon and cayenne if desired. Enjoy!